Pre-Political Condition, aka State of
Nature |
Reasons/Motives for Leaving |
Just Social Order |
Actual (Past or Present) Order |
Hobbes
(1588-1679) * Humans are strictly egoistic in
motivation. * No mine and thine distinct. * Right of nature: to protect one’s life
and interests by any means deemed necessary. *War of each against all. Life is
“nasty, brutish, and short.” |
Fear of violent death. Desire to enjoy comforts made possible
by a stable social order. Hope to attain such a social order. |
Make peace so far as others are
likewise willing. Social contract is a mutual non-aggression pact of each
with all. The Social Contract creates a Common-wealth. But without the next
step it will be unstable: Hobbes favors absolute monarchy.
Anything less risks a return to civil war and the state of nature. |
An actual social order can be compared
with the just social order that emerged from the social contract itself. It
is justified to the extent that it conforms to the just social order. But
Hobbes does not allow for rebellion against unjust rulers.* |
* This
motivates other types of social contract theory, e.g., the social contract
theory of John Locke and the theory of justice
proposed by John Rawls in the 20th century.