Authentic Writing
Persuasive Speaking

The Assignment
 

Presentations
 

Scoring Guide
 

Student Sample
 



The Assignment

Grade Level:  Middle/High School
Class:  Language Arts and Social Studies
Materials Needed: access to a library facility, Internet, current newspapers/magazines and a word processor
Class Time Needed:  3-5 days
Concepts Applied:  Reading, Writing, Speaking, and Critical Thinking

My students were told to think about a real-life social issue in the headlines today and develop a persuasive paper that reflected that specific issue.  The issue could be a social, political, or ethical issue.

The students were told to develop a question that would help them determine their intended audience and the purpose for the speech (this question had to be submitted to me prior to beginning the assignment).  Next, they were told to search for information to support their persuasive speeches and then go about writing a paper that would convince their audience to believe in the same manner in which they believe.  Students were told to state the general cause of the problem, the basic effects of the problem on select individuals or on society as a whole, and then to determine the best course of action for solving the problem.
 
 
 

Back to top of page



Presentations

For the oral presentation portion of this assignment, the students were required to stand at a podium in front of the class and present their arguments using this specific order: The presentations should be delivered in a strong, coherent voice and should last
 no longer than 10 minutes in time.
 
 
 

Back to top of page



Scoring Guide


Each criteria listed is worth up to 10 points each.
 
 

Criteria                                             Score



Written Section:
 
Title page (including student's name) ........
Legibly typed and neat in appearance
Little or no errors in mechanics, (including punctuation & capitalization)
Information relevant and well-organized
Enough support of persuasive topic

Oral Section:
 

Strong beginning statement .....
Used precise language
Used clear, strong voice
Followed the specific order of information given
Strong ending statement
Total Points Received:  ___________________

 
 

Back to top of page



Student Sample:

Dungeons & Dragons
Obsession or Just Another Game

     Oh, come on!  I know you've heard of it.  Dungeons & Dragons (also known as D&D) is a fantasy role-playing game with mythical wizards, evil monsters, and heroic adventurers making their fortunes anyway possible.  In this historic R.P.G. (role-playing game) people role-play a character of their choice and go on brave and daring adventures; whether it be saving a small, peaceful town from danger or ridding the countryside of evil beings.  I know what you're thinking, "Is this guy nuts or what? Doesn't he know that a game like D&D can mess with your head?"  Ha! Anything can get obsessive if you really put your mind to it.  It could be school work, a sports team, video games, etc.  It's just that for some odd reason D&D has been singled out as being obsessive, unhealthy, and even demonic and satanic.  But, hopefully I can change all that.  I know you've heard the bad side of D&D, but if you'll please listen I can tell you why so many D&D gamers view it as just another game.
     As you probably already know, I am a D&D gamer.  A four year veteran, by the way.  Do you know something else about me?  I am a respected Christian of a local Baptist church in my town and a straight A student at my middle school.  I run cross country as a hobby in the summer and as a sport at the high school in the fall.    I have an uncountable number of friends in both middle and high school and consider myself a well-to-do kid.  So what is wrong with being a D&D gamer?  Some aspects of religion may say that D&D is evil because of wizardry and spell casting and that is fine.  Everyone has a right to their own opinion, but people fear what they do not understand.  Dungeons & Dragons is a role-playing game.  When you role-play, you pretend.  You don't actually cast spells.  And don't get me wrong, you don't speak in tongues to cast spells.  You simply say to the dungeon master, "I want to cast a spell."  And there you have it!  The spell is cast in the D&D world and damage is done to the target.  So, I say again, "What is wrong with a D&D gamer?"
     If people don't understand D&D, I really wish they would either play the game once or go to their local bookstore to buy the player's handbook before they label it so harmful.  I really don't think T.S.R, the makers of the game, made D&D to harm or deceive anyone.  Coming straight from a D&D gamer, D&D is not harmful or unhealthy.

*submitted by an 8th grade student at Muhlenberg South Middle School



 

Back to top of page