Name:

Title of Review:

Music Review Scoring Guide


 


Rolling Stone Review
3 points
People Magazine Review
2.5 points
Podunk Press Review
2 points
Weight
Purpose is clear;  review  expresses opinion of author and the reader Review expresses opinion of author Opinion is not expressed effectively        points  x10=
Tone is appropriate for audience; reflects the style of music Some evidence of appropriate tone and audience awareness Inappropriate tone;  no awareness of audience          points  x10=
Introduction grabs the attention of the audience;  sets the tone for the rest of the review Introduction is well written and informs the audience about what album is being reviewed Ineffective introduction         points  x10=
Conclusion sums up the review and pushes the reader to consider the album (or not) Conclusion sums up the author's opinion Ineffective conclusion        points  x10=
Author gives just enough background information to support his/her opinions; refers to other albums Background information is somewhat useful in supporting the author's ideas. Ineffective use of background information         points  x10=
Uses creative descriptive phrases to describe the lyrics and music Some descriptive phrases Descriptive phrases are not used effectively         points  x10=
Discusses and critiques a few songs from the album Discusses every song or only one or two songs from the album No Specific songs are discussed         points  x10=
Total:                /105